Summary (tl;dr)

Keurig Dr Pepper has initiated a recall of over 80,000 McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods because they may contain regular caffeinated coffee instead of decaffeinated.

Essential Background

The current recall follows previous instances of Keurig-related coffee pod issues, such as a July 2025 recall of New Mexico Piñon Coffee's Dark Piñon Single Serve Cups. That recall was due to a packaging flaw where the lid seal was inconsistent, potentially causing food-safe ink to contaminate the coffee during brewing.

The Full Story

Keurig Dr Pepper recently issued a voluntary Class II recall for more than 80,000 of its McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods. The recall stems from the discovery that these pods, which are clearly marked as decaffeinated, might actually contain fully caffeinated coffee. Approximately 960 cartons, each containing 84 pods, were distributed to retailers across California, Indiana, and Nevada. Consumers can identify affected products by checking for a best-by date of "17 NOV 2026" and batch number 5101564894.

Why It Matters

This recall is significant due to potential health implications for individuals sensitive to caffeine. Consuming unexpected caffeine can pose risks for pregnant or breastfeeding individuals, children, and those with certain medical conditions like cardiovascular issues, anxiety disorders, or epilepsy. While the coffee itself is not considered harmful, the mislabeling could lead to temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences for those specifically avoiding caffeine. Consumers with the recalled products are advised to discard them or return them to the retailer for a full refund or replacement.

Geographic Location

• California, United States (distribution of recalled McCafé K-Cup Pods)
• Indiana, United States (distribution of recalled McCafé K-Cup Pods)
• Nevada, United States (distribution of recalled McCafé K-Cup Pods)